Improvement resources can

provide significant impact through

awareness raising or deeper levels

of understanding for the more

experienced


Home > Special Offers > Lean Articles > Archive

Working Lean > archive

Lean Concepts Work Today - and Did 100 Years Ago
This article has been extracted from the Lean Manufacturing Advisor published by Productivity Inc.

Lean's important contribution to IE has been to take the diverse techniques and "make them part of a system."

Some say there's nothing new about lean or TPM; the fundamental concepts have been around forever. Actually it has been nearly 100 years for some of the basic tenets, according to Walton Hancock, professor emeritus of Industrial and Operations Engineering at the University of Michigan. He notes that many of today's lean manufacturing concepts were spawned by Industrial Engineering (IE) ideas, some nearly 100 years old.

He has an interesting take on some of the most significant developments in IE since the turn of the century, their modern lean equivalents, and, most importantly, how lean takes the ideas to the next level. The table below summarizes these pre-lean concepts up to the 1950s.

IE Concept

Lean Equivalent

Frederick Taylor rationalizes work by using the time study to study the interaction between the worker, tools, and materials(early 1900s).

Standard Work Ergonomics

Henry Ford’s assembly line brings material to the worker instead of vice versa (1913).

JIT

Therbligs and the elimination of wasted motions (1920s).

Value-added

Methods Time Measurement establishes time standards using the best method. (1920s)

Standard Work

Statistical Process Control(1920s).

Process control and root cause analysis

Operations Analysis (WW2)

Process Flow

Automation (1950s)

Line Balancing and Total Productive Maintenance

Industry thought "automation was the cure to everything," said Hancock. Actually it "caused a lot of waste" as companies reacted to quality problems in supplied parts by keeping large parts inventories so automated equipment wouldn't stop.

By the end of the 1960s, Toyota had worked out the major concepts of its lean production system. But the West would not begin learning about the Toyota Production System until about 1980.

While IE supplied lean with some of its major concepts and equipped it with key tools, the relationship has not been all one way, said Hancock.

Lean's important contribution to IE has been to take the diverse techniques and "make them part of a system."


Back to Top

Back to Home

 

Current "Working Lean" Article

Lean Production and TPM

 

Previous "Working Lean" Articles

Organising for Lean

The Psychology of Change

Advice for Managing the Change Process Successfully, Year by Year

5S Tip: Know the Hiding Places for Clutter

Lean Concepts Work Today - and Did 100 Years Ago

 
RESOURCES
PUBLICATION
SEARCH